Head to Head Study Confirms Atypical Antipsychotic Efficacy Equivalence
22 Octobre 2005 - 8:00PM
PR Newswire (US)
AMSTERDAM, The Netherlands, October 22 /PRNewswire-FirstCall/ -- -
New data also demonstrate SEROQUEL tolerability benefits versus
other atypicals in schizophrenia and reinforce therapeutic
potential in bipolar disorder Seroquel (quetiapine), olanzapine and
risperidone are equally effective in patients experiencing first
episode psychosis, according to data presented today during the
Breaking News session* at the European College of
Neuropsychopharmacology (ECNP) Congress.[1] The CAFE (Comparison of
Atypicals in First Episode Psychosis) study is the first to examine
the comparative effectiveness of SEROQUEL, olanzapine and
risperidone in first-episode psychosis patients, as measured by
all-cause treatment discontinuation. At week 52, the all-cause
treatment discontinuation rates were similar between medications
(70.9 percent, 68.4 percent and 71.4 percent for SEROQUEL,
olanzapine and risperidone, respectively). However, significantly
more olanzapine patients (80 percent) experienced weight gain of
seven percent or more relative to baseline, compared with 57.6
percent of risperidone and 50 percent of SEROQUEL patients (P=0.01
olanzapine vs SEROQUEL). Commenting on the data, Professor Henry
Nasrallah, Professor of Psychiatry, Neurology, & Neuroscience
at the University of Cincinnati Medical Center, USA said that the
CAFE study shows the three atypicals had similar rates of
discontinuation and similar secondary efficacy outcomes. "These
data confirm that SEROQUEL, olanzapine and risperidone show
equivalent efficacy in the treatment of first episode psychosis. In
addition, they provide clinicians with further guidance on the
optimal dosing for agents such as SEROQUEL in first episode
treatment situations," Professor Nasrallah said. The mean modal
prescribed daily doses in CAFE were 506 mg for SEROQUEL, 11.7 mg
for olanzapine and 2.4 mg for risperidone. However, Professor
Nasrallah said it was important to remember that in chronic
schizophrenia, patients generally need higher doses of medication
and clinicians should explore the full dose ranges of medications.
The overall discontinuation rate observed among patients in this
study reflects the complexities in treating people with
schizophrenia, a severe mental illness which affects about one
percent of people. "The study reinforces the need for a variety of
medications so that clinicians can find the best treatment option,
with optimal risk benefit ratio, for each patient. It also
highlights how important patient-physician communication is in
maximizing treatment success," said Professor Nasrallah. Other data
presented at ECNP confirm that SEROQUEL (final mean dose 709.8 mg)
and risperidone (final mean dose 8.1 mg per day) are equally
effective in the acute management of schizophrenia, however
SEROQUEL offers tolerability benefits.[2] The results of the acute
phase of the TESIS study (Tolerability and Effectiveness of
Seroquel In Patients with Schizophrenia)* show that patients
responded similarly to both medications: 66.3 percent of SEROQUEL
and 57.1 percent of risperidone patients showed at least 40 percent
improvement of Brief Psychiatric Rating Scale scores. More patients
experienced extrapyramidal side-effects (inability to control
muscle movements) with risperidone than with quetiapine: rigidity
(25.7 percent vs 3.8 pecent, P